On LeBron’s Jump Shot, And Not Knowing What You Don’t Know
I recently watched an interview clip where LeBron James was talking about how he developed his jump shot as a kid - I promise this will make sense even if you don’t care about basketball. Like any good basketball player, he idolized Michael Jordan, and he would try to mimic the iconic Jordan fadeaway jump shot in his driveway. LeBron wanted to look like Jordan (who wouldn’t?), so he would try to shoot in a similar manner, even when the circumstances of the moment didn’t call for that shot at all. He also failed to appreciate the underlying balance and footwork involved in the shot, leading something that may have looked like Jordan in his mind, but failed to mimic Jordan in its results.
The clip struck me because I find myself dealing with the same problem with my students so often - it’s hard to even ask the right question, let alone organize your practice, when you don’t understand basic principles of what you’re doing. The more I work with serious students, the more I believe that this is the central thing I’m actually trying to communicate to them: not so much the content of the music itself, but the surrounding framework that guides your exploration of it.
Music is such an individual thing; it can feel like the only lessons you ever remember are the ones you discover yourself. So in a way, I’m less and less inclined towards actually showing a student how to do something. Of course, if they ask, then I will. But I would rather they find it for themselves, and I’d like to be able to show them how to do that, instead of just showing them what it is.
That’s why I’m such a proponent of freedom in your practice, because it leaves space to experiment and find these things for yourself. The more traditional kind of ‘rote’ practice - repeating small sections of a piece of music at increasing tempi until you can play them flawlessly - has its time and place. And in certain musical situations where pure execution is the number one goal (like being a section musician in an orchestra, or the guitarist on a big pop gig), that kind of practice will take precedence. But I’m thinking more along the lines of developing artistry, of finding your musical voice. I think that’s why most of us get into this thing, anyway.
The role of experimentation in that endeavor cannot be overstated. You simply have to spend a lot of time trying stuff out, or imagining you’re in certain situations, or playing the same song for 30 straight minutes just to see what else you come up with on it. Maybe in every hour of that practice, there’s only five minutes of really good stuff worth keeping - that’s fine. You wouldn’t have found those 5 minutes had it not been for the other 55.
Back to LeBron - the fundamental mistake he made as a kid was not that he tried to mimic a great predecessor - that was actually the best thing to do at that point in his development. It was instead that he failed to realize the underlying mechanism of why the thing worked in the first place. He did not investigate it deeply enough, so his experimentation and mimicry was only ever going to be superficial.
In music, it’s the same idea with our listening. In order to do this kind of experimentation effectively, you have to have the right idea of what you’re even going for in the first place (nobody invents music from scratch, after all). That idea is shaped by your knowledge and interpretation of recordings, or shows you’ve seen - but if you’re not listening deeply enough, you’ll have an incomplete picture of what those things actually represent. Again, it’s hard to ask the right questions when you can’t picture things in the right framework.
A part of me wonders if the current climate, both in music education and the world at large, contributes to this. Sometimes there’s an element of “hustle culture” to learning music that I just can’t stand. Tracking your practice, optimizing everything, coming up with a system, trying to be the most efficient practicer there ever was. Isn’t music supposed to be fun? That’s not to say you should just dilly-dally and noodle around for a few minutes and call it your practice, as there’s always going to be an incredible amount of hard work (and grunt work) involved in getting good. But I find this kind of optimization-seeking tends to strip all of the artistry out of the music with amazing efficiency.
I just can’t imagine any of my heroes practicing like that. Do you think Jimi Hendrix kept a practice journal, or forced himself to practice his scales for 20 minutes before working on anything else? No. He just sat down and played the guitar, and he did it for so many hours, and with such dedication, that he wound up as probably the best to ever do it.
This attitude is much more pervasive among students in their first few years of serious study; perhaps their hope is to speed-run their way to mastery. I don’t really know why people think music works like that, while other disciplines don’t. If you can’t make scrambled eggs, it’s probably not time to start working on writing your first cookbook! But that’s basically what you’re doing by setting a strict practice routine for yourself at that stage. In your first few years of learning to play music, you should basically have three guiding lights that you’re working towards: I need to get better at my instrument, I need to learn how to actually hear (not just theoretically understand) what’s happening in music, and I need to have fun while doing all of it. Music is a lifelong endeavor, and you’ll only ever get where you’re hoping to go if you treat it as such. Your practice should not be organized around the idea of being better in a week, it’s about finding yourself still playing in 20 years.
The element of organization and goal-setting is still important in all of this, but more as a way of orienting yourself towards a big idea, rather than a daily regiment. For example, you may find through your listening that one thing basically every great musician does is phrase melodies really well. Wouldn’t it be great if you developed the same thing in your musicianship? Ding-ding-ding! Congratulations, you found the framework! Now how do you actually practice that? It’s hard, but one place to start is just trying to do it yourself.
Okay, you try to do the same thing yourself and find it isn’t sounding like that great musician you admire. That’s fine - no one gets phrasing right the first time. Now you go back to listening - what concrete techniques are they using to get that sound? Aha, you notice, it helps that their time is really strong, which allows them to phrase around the beat rather than being glued to it. Unfortunately, your time is not that strong, and when you try to do that, you end up losing your place in the beat. Now we get to something more concrete - you need to spend more time practicing with a metronome, because your time isn’t strong enough to support the kind of phrasing you want to play with. For the next good chunk of time (months to years!), you center a big portion of your practice and experimentation around that idea - you need to develop better time, and the metronome is going to help you get there. Before you know it, you’re noticeably better at this fundamental skill.
When I think about it, that’s kind of how I practice everything. A big idea leads to investigation, which leads to experimentation, which leads to a discovery of my own deficiencies; and now I know what I actually need to work on. But if you try to do that in the reverse order, say, “I know having good time is important, because my teacher told me so, so I guess I’ll work on metronome stuff,” you won’t understand the framework! Without discovering why it’s important to have great time in music first, you won’t know what it is you’re actually looking for with the metronome.
I think the final lesson from that LeBron anecdote is this: he made a fundamental mistake regarding an extremely important part of the craft, at a critical juncture in his development. And he still managed to author the greatest career in the history of the sport. That’s the thing about letting your curiosity guide you - it may steer you wrong, but it will steer you right more often than not.